It’s 1999. MySpace, Facebook and Reddit are years away.

Entrepreneur Jeffrey Gilbert runs The Dilly, a forum for high school and college students. He asks me to help with an ambitious redesign, heavily focused on member profiles and community interaction.

BADGES WERE HOT

Verified members already had profile badges, but we wondered what other kinds of engagement we could incentivize with similar, collectible rewards.

Pixel art award with a yellow checkmark in the center, surrounded by smaller yellow icons on a brown ribbon background.

EMOJI WERE NOT

Early emoji were pretty basic. We envisioned big, expressive profile avatars that would reflect the community’s young and rebellious counter-culture.

Pixel art of a large yellow smiley face in the center, surrounded by smaller emoji faces expressing different emotions such as happiness, sadness, crying, and laughter, on a black background.

THE HUNT WAS ON

These trophies would release in secret, with no instructions. When a new one appeared on someone’s profile, other members rushed to figure out how to unlock it.

Pixel art illustration of a taco with a yellow shell, brown meat, and some yellow toppings, divided into sections.
Three young men sitting on a bench, two wearing sunglasses, one with a laptop, all looking serious or focused. The setting appears to be a lobby or waiting area with a door and windows to the outside.

We were here.

“The Rank Icons” became coveted status symbols for members and popular mascots for the company. At its height, The Dilly had become the underground clubhouse for nearly a million of the Internet’s coolest kids— a quaint number today, but a proud feat for three misfits who didn’t realize they were building one of the first modern social networks.